How to write a peer review of an article

Share via Email Reviewing is a good way to keep up with literature and sharpen your own writing, says Brian Lucey.

How to write a peer review of an article

how to write a peer review of an article

How to Write an Employee Peer Review by Christina Hamlett - Updated September 26, In an earlier era of management, employee performance appraisals were always conducted by a supervisor or the owner of the business. The employee peer review is an opportunity for members of a workplace team to critique one another and provide constructive feedback on how they can all do a better and more productive job.

This involves a combination of 1 reviewing the assignment documents i. Create a list of positive and negative character traits that you have witnessed first-hand. For instance, perhaps your office team member has excellent intermediary skills and the ability to come up with creative compromises and yet has a tendency to procrastinate on her own deadlines or not proofread her activity reports as thoroughly as she should.

Language & Lit

Discuss how the behaviors identified in Step 2 impact her interactions with others, her professional development, and the reputation and growth of the company. For example, procrastination not only keeps the project from being completed on time but could also preclude the company from competing successfully with others in landing lucrative contracts.

In praising positive traits, point out how her calm demeanor and encouragement of others to participate in discussions reflect a leadership style that could be honed through additional training. Identify specific instances of tasks that were performed well and tasks that fell short of expectations.

Provide constructive suggestions on how similar tasks could be handled in the future. For example, a project that was incomplete may have been the result of the employee having more assignments than she could realistically handle or the inability to analyze and prioritize those assignments that needed more time and research.

Recommend action steps and timelines to remedy existing problems. Tips Always say something positive at the beginning of the peer review since this will put the employee in a more willing frame of mind to accept subsequent observations that are less favorable.

If the peer evaluation is done in person instead of on paper, always allow time for your peer to respond to the items discussed.

Home - Evaluating Information Sources - LibGuides at John Jay College of Criminal Justice, CUNY

Warning Refrain from saying "always" and "never" in a peer review.Mar 06,  · Though starting to write the review article promptly seems to be very alluring, the time you spend for the determination of important issues won’t be a waste of time. [ 9 ] The PRISMA statement [ 6 ] elaborated to write a well-designed review articles contains a item checklist (Table 1).

It's called peer review for a reason. You, putative reviewer, are the peer. If you don't do it for them why should they do it for you? This is a . Peer review of a review article Gustavo Gutierrez Gonzalez says: Hydbring and Badalian-Very summarize in this review, the current status in the potential .

Featured peer reviews. Below are a few of Peerage of Science peer reviews with high PEQ-scores, featured as examples of what good but critical peer review looks like.. As the manuscripts under review are not yet published, the manuscript title and some peer review content is censored. on the peer review process, a defining fea-ture of scientific discourse that subjects the literature forming the foundation of cred- After this first pass, write the first two paragraphs of your review, which will sum-marize the research question addressed and the contribution of the work.

If the jour-. An Article Review is a critical, constructive evaluation of literature in a particular field through summary, classification, analysis, and comparison.

How to Write an Employee Peer Review | Bizfluent